Rwanda put more than a million people on trial for the genocide against the Tutsi. In those trials, its courts awarded survivors damages worth close to $100 million. Almost none of it has been paid.
This page sets out the record for researchers, students and survivors: who judged the genocide, what survivors won in court, and how the door to reparation was closed. I was a lawyer for survivors’ organizations in Rwanda. Where I give my own view, I say so.
In brief Who judged, and when What survivors won How the door closed Timeline Quick answers Sources
In brief
$100 millionOr close to it: the damages Rwandan courts had awarded survivors after the first 4,000 or so genocide trials.
NoneOf the awards made against the Rwandan State has been enforced.
15,800Francs survivors recovered out of a 17 million franc award against Froduald Karamira, a leader of the genocide who was executed in 1998.
92%Of genocide-related judgments were still unenforced among more than 2,700 claimants surveyed by Rwanda’s Legal Aid Forum in 2012.
Source for all four: Right to Reparation for Survivors, discussion paper by IBUKA, SURF, AERG, REDRESS and others (October 2012, PDF).
Who judged the genocide, and when
Most of those tried stood before gacaca (ga-CHA-cha), community courts held outdoors on the hills where the killings happened. A UN tribunal tried the leaders, and courts in other countries have tried a few dozen more. The news site JusticeInfo calls it the most judged genocide in history.
Where a million people were tried
Each square stands for 10,000 people.
1,003,227people tried by gacaca courts
About 10,000people tried by Rwanda’s ordinary courts
93people indicted by the UN tribunal
31people tried by courts in other countries
Gacaca counted cases as well as people: 1,958,634 cases, because one person could be tried in several places. Killers moved from hill to hill.
Who was judging, and when
1994 to 2026. Thick bar: the main years of trials. Thin line: open, but only a few cases a year.
UN tribunal1994 to 2015. A small UN office has finished its cases since.
Rwanda’s ordinary courtsSince December 1996. Mass trials until 2005.
Gacaca community courtsPilot courts 2002. Trials 2005 to 2012.
Courts in other countriesSince 1999. Nine countries so far.
Damages for survivorsAwarded 1997 to 2001. Property only under gacaca. Nothing since 2012.
What survivors won
Punishing the killers is only half of justice. Rwanda’s 1996 genocide law let survivors join a criminal trial as civil parties, which means claiming damages in the same case (Organic Law 08/96, Art. 29). It also made the planners of the genocide liable for all the damage done in the country (Art. 30).
For a few years survivors did exactly that. They were civil parties in about two out of three trials, and about half of those who asked for damages got an award. Judges heard them, put a figure on their losses and wrote it into the verdict.
In several cases the judges went further and ordered the Rwandan State to pay jointly with the convicted, because the genocide was organized by the government of the day and carried out with its army, its mayors and its radio. A study of 159 judgments by Avocats Sans Frontières (Lawyers Without Borders) in 2000 found damages awarded in half of them, the State condemned in seven, and not one award paid.
How the door closed
How does a court ruling turn into a piece of paper? In four steps.
- The convicted could not pay. Most had nothing, or hid what they had. That left the State.
- A minister told the courts to stop. By 2000, a minister of justice had written to the courts telling them to suspend every case in which the State was called to answer.
- The law shut the State out. The 2001 gacaca law said any civil claim against the State must be declared inadmissible, because the State had acknowledged its role in the genocide and paid part of its budget into a fund for survivors (Organic Law 40/2000, Art. 91). Awards already made against the State were dismissed, as survivors’ organizations and REDRESS later documented.
- Gacaca could only return property. Two out of three gacaca cases, 1,320,554 of them, were about looted or destroyed property. The courts could order it returned or paid for. They could not award a franc for a murdered parent or child.
In exchange, the law promised a compensation fund. A draft law to create it was written in 2001 and again in 2003. It was never passed. When gacaca closed in 2012, the closing law said genocide damages would be governed by a separate law (Organic Law 04/2012, Art. 3). That law has not been passed either.
What survivors got instead was FARG, an assistance fund created in 1998 that paid school fees, health care and housing for the neediest. It helped many of us, and I was one of them. But assistance is not reparation, and the government closed FARG in 2021. Our 2012 campaign for a reparation fund was shelved too.
My view
Genocide is a crime of state. It took a government, an army and a civil service to kill a million people in a hundred days, and Rwanda’s own judges said so when they ordered the State to pay. The government that came after inherited that debt along with the country. Instead it excused itself and left survivors to collect from prisoners who own nothing.
Survivors still keep their copies of those judgments, with awards of millions of francs written on them, while they grow old in poverty. I do not know of one who has been paid. Many have died waiting.
And yet this is the most judged genocide there has been. After the Holocaust, courts in West Germany convicted about 6,650 people, and thousands of former Nazis grew old and died free. After the Armenian genocide, an Ottoman court sentenced the organizers to death in their absence in 1919, and the trials were soon abandoned. Rwanda tried a million. Whatever one thinks of the quality of those trials or the politics around them, that record stands. What it has not done is repair the people in whose name it was done.
Albert Gasake
Timeline: 1994 to today
Tap a date to open it. The purple entry is from my own work.
November 8, 1994 The UN creates a tribunal. Rwanda votes against it.
The Security Council set up the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) by 13 votes to 1, with China abstaining. The one vote against was Rwanda’s, which held a seat on the Council that year (Resolution 955).
The new government had asked for a tribunal. It objected that this one would cover only 1994, could not impose the death penalty and would sit outside Rwanda (Council record S/PV.3453). It sat in Arusha, Tanzania.
August 30, 1996 Rwanda writes its own genocide law
Organic Law 08/96 created specialized chambers inside the ordinary and military courts to try genocide and crimes against humanity committed since October 1, 1990. It sorted suspects into four categories, from the planners down to people who only took property, offered lighter sentences to those who confessed, and let survivors claim damages as civil parties.
December 27, 1996 The first trials open in Kibungo
The first two defendants were tried in a few hours, without lawyers, and sentenced to death. Trials improved as lawyers arrived. Many came through Avocats Sans Frontières, which defended the accused and also represented survivors.
On April 24, 1998, 22 people convicted of genocide were shot in public. There were no more executions, and Rwanda abolished the death penalty in 2007. By 1998 the prisons held about 130,000 people in space built for 12,000, by Human Rights Watch’s count.
1997 to 2001 Courts award survivors damages, and name the State
In their busiest year, 2000, the courts tried 2,458 people. At that pace, officials estimated, it would take some 200 years to try everyone in prison. What survivors won in those years.
1998 FARG, an assistance fund, is created
The Fonds d’assistance aux rescapés du génocide paid school fees, health care and housing for the neediest survivors, mostly from the State budget. The government has pointed to it ever since as its answer on reparation.
September 2, 1998 The first genocide conviction by an international court
The ICTR convicted Jean-Paul Akayesu, a former mayor, of genocide. No international court had convicted anyone of that crime before. The judges also ruled that rape can be an act of genocide. The tribunal had no power to award survivors anything.
April 30, 1999 The first verdict in a foreign court
A Swiss military court convicted Fulgence Niyonteze, a former mayor, of war crimes. Belgium followed in 2001 with the trial of the “Butare Four.” These trials rest on universal jurisdiction: the idea that the gravest crimes can be tried anywhere, wherever they were committed. Cases by country.
January 26, 2001 The gacaca law bars claims against the State
Organic Law 40/2000 created the gacaca courts: panels of neighbors elected for their integrity, sitting without lawyers in every community. Ordinary courts kept the Category 1 cases. Article 91 made civil claims against the State inadmissible.
June 18, 2002 Gacaca begins
Pilot courts opened in 12 sectors. Communities spent the next years drawing up lists of the dead, the losses and the accused. Trials began in March 2005 and reached the whole country in July 2006.
In 2008 most of the remaining Category 1 cases, including at least 8,000 cases of rape, were moved from the ordinary courts to gacaca.
June 18, 2012 Gacaca closes
Ten years to the day after it opened, gacaca closed with 1,958,634 cases tried against 1,003,227 people. Unfinished cases went to the ordinary courts. So did the files of 71,658 people convicted in their absence, most of whom have never been caught.
October 2012 · My work Survivors ask for a reparation fund
I was legal advisor at the Survivors Fund (SURF) when ten organizations, including IBUKA, the main survivors’ association, sent the government a discussion paper on the right to reparation. In 2014 the Ministry of Justice agreed to a study of how reparations could be delivered. The study was never published. The full story.
December 31, 2015 The UN tribunal closes
In 21 years the ICTR indicted 93 people. It sentenced 62, acquitted 14 and sent 10 cases to national courts. Its unfinished work passed to a smaller UN office, the Residual Mechanism (IRMCT).
2021 FARG is closed
The government closed the survivors’ assistance fund. No reparation program replaced it.
Today The trials go on. The judgments are still unpaid.
A Dutch court handed down a life sentence in August 2026, and a trial opened in Paris on November 17. Follow the cases on the fugitive tracker. In Rwanda, there is still no compensation law.
Quick answers
Did the UN tribunal award reparations to survivors?
No. The ICTR had no power to award compensation. Its rules left victims to claim damages in national courts, using the tribunal’s judgment as proof of guilt.
Can survivors sue the Rwandan State for the genocide?
Not since 2001. The gacaca law of that year made civil claims against the State inadmissible (Organic Law 40/2000, Art. 91). A 2008 law went further: only the assistance fund, FARG, could bring a civil action against those convicted in Category 1 (Law 69/2008, Art. 20, as cited in the 2012 discussion paper).
What could gacaca courts order?
The return of looted or destroyed property, or its value. They could not award moral damages, which is what the law calls compensation for the loss of a relative.
Was FARG reparation?
The government has presented it that way. Survivors’ organizations say it was not: FARG was assistance for the neediest, paid according to need and not according to what a court had awarded.
How much are survivors owed in total?
No one knows. The 2012 discussion paper found that the gacaca courts never compiled a list of the damages and losses they recorded, and no one has counted the unpaid awards of the ordinary courts.
Sources and documents
- IBUKA, SURF, AERG, REDRESS and others, Right to Reparation for Survivors, discussion paper (October 2012, PDF).
- Albert Gasake, “Post-Gacaca Compensation for Survivors: A Missed Opportunity for Reconciliation in Rwanda” (Survivors Fund, 2013, PDF).
- Stef Vandeginste, “Réparation pour les victimes de génocide, de crimes contre l’humanité et de crimes de guerre au Rwanda”, L’Afrique des Grands Lacs, Annuaire 2000–2001 (PDF, French). It reports the Avocats Sans Frontières study of 159 judgments and the minister’s letter.
- Organic Law 08/96 of August 30, 1996, on the prosecution of genocide and crimes against humanity committed since October 1, 1990 (PDF, English).
- National Service of Gacaca Courts, final report of the gacaca courts (2012, PDF, Kinyarwanda).
- Projet de loi portant création du fonds d’indemnisation pour les victimes du génocide, draft law on a compensation fund (2003, PDF, French).
- William Schabas, “Genocide Trials and Gacaca Courts,” Journal of International Criminal Justice (2005).
- Human Rights Watch, Justice Compromised: The Legacy of Rwanda’s Community-Based Gacaca Courts (2011).
- Avocats Sans Frontières, case law collections and reports on genocide trials in Rwanda (French).
- JusticeInfo, “Rwanda: The most judged genocide in history” (2019) and “Deux décennies après, toujours pas de mécanisme de réparation” (2016, French).
- United Nations, “The Justice and Reconciliation Process in Rwanda”, background note (2014, PDF).
- All my stories on reparations.
Researching this, or holding one of these judgments yourself? Write to me.
Keep exploring
Fugitive tracker Survivors in numbers The 101 Memorials Invite me to speak